The first recorded law enforcement action in Pinole involved one of the Bay Area's most famous western lawmen, Harry N. Morse who was the third Sheriff of Alameda County and one of the most famous gunfighters of his time as documented in John Boessenecker's book, Lawman. Few people know one of Sheriff Morse's famous gunfights occurred here in Pinole before it was a town:
One of the most desperate gunfights in old Contra Costa occurred in 1867. Narato Ponce was a notorious East Bay thug, murderer and horse thief. The Governor of California, Frederick Low, placed a $500 bounty on Ponce's head. During a bloody gun battle at the present intersection of Highway 580 and Santa Rita Road in Pleasanton, Ponce was nearly shot to pieces by Alameda County Sheriff Harry Morse. Ponce was wounded, but he escaped and fled into the Black Hills of Contra Costa County.
Law officers later learned that Narato Ponce was hiding somewhere in Pinole near the San Pablo Bay. The lawmen began systematically searching the scattered adobes dotting the Pinole Valley. At the upper end of the canyon was the adobe located next to Pinole Creek (near modern day Adobe Road). When officers found Ponce hiding in the adobe, he attempted to flee up the canyon. Gunshots were exchanged and Ponce was wounded in the right hand. Finally cornered, the killer stepped to the edge of the creek, and took careful aim at Sheriff Morse with a six-gun in his left hand. Incredibly Sheriff Morse squeezed the trigger of his rifle a split second before Ponce and killed the desperado, Ponce. The affair was warmly applauded by the entire law-abiding community of Alameda and Contra Costa Counties.
Very little is known of Pinole's law enforcement history from 1868 to1903; however when the Town of Pinole was incorporated in 1903, we find the first reference to the town's law enforcement. The first Town of Pinole minutes, a 1903 document, record a motion made that the Town "Marshall be allowed dollars to purchase a pistol, badge, and outfit." Although other historical records refer to Pinole's early law enforcement officers as Constables, the Town of Pinole minutes refer to them as Marshals.
The first Marshal of the newly incorporated Town of Pinole, John Collins, operated the Klondike Saloon, named after the 1897 Klondike gold rush, and the saloon still stands at 612 Tennent Avenue, which is a few blocks away from Pinole's once grand seaport and the current Bayfront Park. The port served as a main supply location for the Town and a stopover for travelers moving up the coast for the gold rush.
For John Collins, and the other early Town Marshals, Pinole was a rough and tumble place. In the early years there were banditos, brothels, gambling halls, opium dens, theaters, and dance halls throughout Contra Costa County. Some of the early crime reports from the Town of Pinole included everything from horse theft to the occasional murder, which were often both hanging offenses.
Arthur "Jerry" McDonald was the Town of Pinole's second Marshal/Constable. He was appointed as the Contra Costa County District 11 Constable in 1918. His jurisdiction ran from Pinole to Crockett. Constable McDonald, a former Hercules Powder Plant foreman and co-owner of McDonald's & Company Clothing, which sold items of the highest fashion, thrived in the rambunctious environment of Pinole saloons, hotels, and theaters. The 1920s changed the Wild West atmosphere of the town. Veterans were returning from World War I and social clubs, sports teams, and fraternal organizations thrived.
In 1926 a municipal building was erected which housed Pinole's first one cell jail and it was during this period Pinole's first law enforcement officer was killed in the line-of-duty. On September 26, 1929, the Rodeo branch of the Bank of Pinole was robbed by the infamous Fleagle gang, one of whom was armed with a Colt Thompson submachine gun. Constable Arthur McDonald was working bank security when the robbery occurred. A gunfight ensued, which left Constable McDonald dead and one robber wounded. The robbers got away after fleeing through Pinole Valley and pushing the getaway car over a cliff in the Berkeley Hills.
Constable McDonald was replaced by long time Pinole resident and Irish immigrant Gene Shea, who served as Pinole's last constable. Shea worked side-by-side with Pinole's first part-time Traffic Police Officers, who were hired to address the ever growing traffic issues on Highway 40 (now San Pablo Avenue). Shea kept busy with drunken servicemen trying to find something to do during lengthy train layovers, and German saboteurs trying to set fire to the railroad tracks.